What archaeology says
Scholars can reconstruct Mu's genealogy with unusual precision, because every link is documented and every link is broken. Brasseur de Bourbourg attempted to read the Troano manuscript (part of the Madrid Codex) using Bishop Diego de Landa's colonial-era 'alphabet' — which is not an alphabet at all, since Maya script is logosyllabic, a fact not established until Yuri Knorozov's work in the 1950s. Brasseur's 'translation', including glyphs he read as the letters M and U naming a drowned land, is gibberish; the codex is actually an almanac of astronomy, astrology and ritual. Augustus Le Plongeon, an early photographer of Yucatán ruins, built on Brasseur to produce his saga of Queen Móo of Mu, who fled the cataclysm to found Egypt — inverting real chronology, since the Maya cities he dug are millennia younger than the Egyptian civilisation they supposedly spawned. James Churchward then claimed that as a young officer in India he had been shown the 'Naacal tablets' by a temple priest, recording Mu's history in a primal language only he was taught to read. He never produced the tablets, never named the monastery, and never published verifiable translations.
Geophysics closes the case independently. The Pacific floor is young oceanic basalt, continuously created at spreading ridges and recycled into trenches; it is compositionally incapable of concealing a foundered granite continent, and bathymetric mapping shows none. Pacific islands are volcanic peaks, coral atolls and island-arc fragments, and their human settlement is recent and well understood: the Austronesian expansion and the Polynesian voyages that reached the remote Pacific mostly within the last 3,000 years. The megalithic sites claimed for Mu dissolve on inspection — Nan Madol's basalt city on Pohnpei was built from about AD 1180 by the local Saudeleur dynasty, and Yonaguni's terraces are read by most geologists as naturally fractured sandstone (see this site's entries on both).
- Maya script is logosyllabic; Brasseur's de Landa-alphabet 'translation' that produced the name Mu is universally recognised as invalid
- Churchward's Naacal tablets were never produced, located or independently examined by anyone
- The Pacific floor is young oceanic crust with no continental root — a sunken continent there is geophysically impossible
- Nan Madol is radiocarbon-dated to c. AD 1180 onward and attributed to the local Saudeleur dynasty
- Pacific settlement is explained by the well-documented Austronesian and Polynesian expansions, with no Mu substrate in genetics or linguistics
